Choosing the Right Bilge Pump for Your Boat
When the bilge pump is the only thing that can prevent your boat from sinking, it’s best to have one capable of handling the burden of pumping out as many gallons of water out as fast as it can.
All boats collect nuisance water within the hull. This water typically comes from waves, spray, rain and leaking thru-hull fittings, but can also come from virtually anything from melting snow to the water people bring onboard with them. Even small amounts of water in the bilge can destabilize a boat. Bilge water can also spread spilt oil and fuel around the hull, which can damage plastic and rubber components, and lead to blistering in fiberglass hulls. Enough bilge water within a hull can sink an entire boat.
How Many Bilge Pumps?
All powerboats have a standard bilge pump to deal with the nuisance water that collects within the hull. These are submersible electrical pumps found in the lowest part of the hull, typically the stern.
Standard pumps are usually small and only capable of removing low volumes of nuisance water. They’re often incapable of dealing with large quantities of water from emergency situations caused by a hull breach, or the total failure of a through-hull fitting or seacock. Because of a standard bilge pump’s limited capabilities, installing a second, larger bilge pump capable of expelling more water in emergency situations is highly recommended. On boats with multiple hull compartments, you’ll need a standard bilge pump for each compartment, plus an emergency bilge.
What Size Bilge Pump?
When it comes to bilge pumps, bigger is always better, provided a larger capacity pump can fit where it needs to be installed. Bilge pumps are rated by the number of gallons per hour they can pump. However, the actual performance of a pump is always lower than its given pumping capacity. For example, a pump rated at 200 GPH (gallons per hour) might only be capable of pumping 120 GPH.
Standard Bilge Pumps
Most standard bilge pumps aren’t capable of pumping much water, so consider upgrading to higher capacity pumps, even if your boat is new. If the standard electrical bilge pump in your boat’s hull isn't capable of preventing your boat from sinking, it should at least be able to pump out enough water to buy you the time needed to find and plug a leak in the hull.
Emergency Bilge Pumps
An emergency bilge pump needs to be capable of pumping hundreds of gallons per minute to save your boat. High-capacity emergency bilge pumps might be expensive, but will seldom (if ever) be used and shouldn’t wear out. Ultimately, if a more expensive emergency pump ends up saving your boat from sinking, it’s worth the investment. Emergency bilge pumps can also be mounted higher up in the boat so they aren’t submerged in nuisance water, and can last longer than standard pumps.
Bilge Pump Accessibility
When buying a new bilge pump, consider how accessible it’ll be. Not only will the pump have to fit into a specific space, but it needs to be easily accessible for routine inspection, maintenance and repairs. This applies more to standard bilge pumps that have to be mounted at the very bottom of the hull than emergency pumps, which have more flexibility on where they can be installed.
Diaphragm Bilge Pumps vs. Centrifugal Bilge Pumps
Diaphragm Bilge Pumps
A diaphragm bilge pump uses the movement of a rubber or plastic diaphragm to draw water in through an intake valve, and then out through an output valve to the discharge pipe.
Pros: Extremely efficient at pumping water upward against gravitational forces. Self-priming, and can be mounted above water.
Cons: Easily clogged by debris and thus requires adequate screens or filters, which require regular inspection and cleaning. Can’t pump the same volume of water as a same-sized centrifugal pump.
- Diaphragm pumps are more suitable as emergency bilge pumps.
Diaphragm bilge pump
Centrifugal bilge pump
Centrifugal Bilge Pumps
A centrifugal bilge pump uses the movement of a spinning impeller to suck water into the pump housing and out through the discharge pipe.
Pros: Extremely efficient at pumping large volumes of water. Less susceptible to debris within the water being pumped. Very reliable and low maintenance.
Cons: Can’t pump water as high as a same-sized diaphragm pump. Not self-priming, so it must be mounted below water level.
- Centrifugal pumps are more suitable as standard bilge pumps.
Automatic Bilge Pumps
These bilge pumps have built-in float switches that turn the pump on when bilge water is detected. If you can’t find an automatic pump suitable for your boat, buy a separate float switch and pair it with a non-automatic pump.
And if you do have an automatic bilge system, you should still check the bilge regularly for signs of problems. Your boat’s bilge pump might be able to cope with an old thru-hull fitting that is starting to leak, but once the fitting fails completely, the pump will be overwhelmed. A bilge water alarm that warns you when the level of the bilge water rises is a sensible addition to any bilge system.
Electric Bilge Pumps vs. Manual Bilge Pumps
An electrically powered bilge pump sounds like a better option than a manually operated bilge pump, but isn’t necessarily the best choice.
In an emergency flooding situation, a boat’s electrical system can short out, rendering an electric bilge pump useless. Instead, a bilge system that includes both an electric and a manual bilge pump for emergency use is recommended. The most important thing to look for with a manual pump is ease of use. Pumping hundreds of gallons by hand is exhausting, so a manual pump with a high pumping capacity is recommended.
Replacing a bilge pump is much easier if you choose a new pump that uses the same size hoses and pipes as the old one. Otherwise, you’ll need to replace the various hoses, pipes and thru-hull fittings for a higher-capacity pump. Also, add a non-return valve or check valve to the discharge pipe to prevent water in the pipe from flowing back into the bilge when the pump is turned off.
Need assistance finding the right bilge pump for your boat? Contact Boats.net and we'll be happy to help you out!